Best Non-Toxic Cookware: Expert-Tested Recommendations

All items showcased in Bon Appétit are chosen exclusively by the magazine’s editors. Nonetheless, whenever purchases are made via their retail links, Condé Nast might receive an affiliate commission.

If you’ve browsed for cooking utensils In recent years, you might have come across the phrase "nontoxic cookware." Perhaps you've looked into this topic yourself. best Non-toxic cookware has become quite popular, but many people aren’t entirely clear about which specific toxins they should avoid. However, do you know precisely what this non-toxic label means? Also, how does traditional 'toxic' cookware compare to the so-called ‘healthier’ or ‘safer’ options available today? If you're clueless about substances like PFAS—or perhaps well-versed in their near-century-long background—and seeking top-notch suggestions from us regarding products free of such materials based on extensive research, then look no further. Continue reading for comprehensive insights into everything related to non-toxic (and non-stick) kitchenware.

The best nontoxic cookware

• For someone who isn’t quite prepared to say farewell to their coated nonstick just yet: GreenPan Paris Pro
• A low-maintenance kitchen allstar: All-Clad D3 Stainless Steel Frying Pan
• A robust, family-passdown item that requires merely some tender care: Lancaster Cast Iron Skillet
• For easy handling and non-stick properties that compete with Teflon: Merten and Stork Carbon Steel

Wait, cooking utensils can be harmful?

When businesses label their kitchenware as "nontoxic," they usually promote these products as healthier choices compared to conventional nonstick items, which often have a coating made from a substance known as polytetrafluoroethylene (or PTFE for brevity). accidentally In 1938, and later branded by the chemicals firm DuPont as Teflon around the beginning of the '60s, PTFE dramatically transformed domestic cooking during the latter part of the 20th century through offering an entirely non-stick, oil-free cooking area that was widely adopted. As we entered the new millennium, Teflon had become prevalent across numerous U.S. households, appearing frequently in various kitchenware like PTFE-lined frying pans, cupcake molds, baking containers, among others.

PTFE is merely one among thousands of compounds known as per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, or PFAS. PFAS Around 1951, DuPont began utilizing another type of PFAS known as PFOA (short for perfluorooctanoic acid) during their Teflon production. Eventually, it was discovered that PFOA might enter the human body through inhalation of fumes or ingestion from worn-out coatings and could have extremely detrimental effects Regarding human health and environmental impacts—which include heightened risks for specific types of cancer, birth defects, ulcerative colitis, and thyroid disorders—by 2013, producers had ceased its use.

Nowadays, conventional nonstick cookware is manufactured with PFOA-free PTFE, which usually lacks additional substances as well. PFOS , another detrimental PFAS). This substance goes by numerous names such as T-fal, hard-anodized aluminum, and Dura-Slide, among others. While PTFE has been recognized as considerably less hazardous compared to certain other PFAS compounds, it's important to acknowledge that potential risks may still persist. ongoing research Into the broader category of chemicals—as there are numerous less well-known PFAS compounds that remain unregulated because we lack understanding of their impacts, and these could appear in items claiming to be "PFOS- and PFOA-free."

What is the actual definition of "nontoxic cookware"?

Although it may not have been the earliest documented usage, the concept of "nontoxic" cookware primarily came into consumer awareness when GreenPan In 2007, they released the initial batch of PFAS-free ceramic nonstick frying pans. From that point onward, "nontoxic cookware" has largely come to mean "PFAS-free nonstick cookware." Although this description isn’t technically wrong, it's crucial to understand how much it has turned into a marketing catchphrase over time.

When people talk about "nontoxic cookware," they usually mean cookware with a ceramic nonstick coating, which is created using silica through a method known as the sol-gel process. any Cookware manufactured without using harmful substances such as PFAS can be deemed "nontoxic." This category encompasses several varieties you might already be familiar with and enjoy: specifically, stainless steel, cast iron, and carbon steel.

What's up with ceramic nonstick cookware?

You might know ceramic nonstick as the preferred coating used by numerous stylish, social-media-popular cookware brands that emerged around the late 2010s (hello, Our Place and Caraway). To recap, these ceramic nonstick pans do away with PFAS entirely. They use a silicate-based gel which is applied and cured onto the metallic base to form a slick surface. It sounds promising, doesn’t it? However, there are some drawbacks worth mentioning; primarily, ceramic nonstick tends not to endure over time. So, remember to steer clear of metal utensils and choose wooden or silicone ones instead when preparing your meals. Additionally, keep them away from very high heat levels since even ceramic cookware has its limits. technically more heat tolerant Unlike PTFE-based cookware, high heat can diminish the durability of a ceramic-coated pan. While many producers assert that their pans are safe in ovens up to specific (usually elevated) temperatures, we suggest opting for alternative options listed below when transferring between stovetop and oven use. These repeated transitions to the oven can gradually erode the ceramic coating over time. Additionally, even though some of these pans may be labeled as dishwasher-safe, washing them by hand will help extend their longevity.

What is the most non-toxic type of cookware available?

Despite treating your ceramic nonstick cookware carefully, anticipate its lifespan to extend only up to one to three years before losing its nonstick qualities. Therefore, the highest quality nontoxic "nonstick" cookware isn’t always free from PFOA or PFAS; instead, consider opting for stainless steel, cast iron, or carbon steel options. Although these materials aren't advertised as inherently nonstick, they possess such characteristics when properly used and maintained.

The main point is that nobody really does this. needs A nonstick-coated pan isn't essential at all. We can assure you that there’s not a single recipe on our site—or anywhere—that necessitates using one. Instead, we suggest dedicating effort into mastering cooking techniques with sturdier types of cookware rather than splurging on an entire set of nonstick pans. However, for those seeking substitutes to conventional PTFE-based nonstick cookware, we’ve provided various options here. This includes a ceramic choice for individuals who haven’t completely moved away from nonstick surfaces yet.

The top choices for ceramic nonstick cookware include the GreenPan Valencia Pro and the GreenPan Paris Pro.

Valencia Pro Ceramic Nonstick 12-Inch Fry Pan

$130.00, GreenPan

GreenPan Paris Pro Ceramic Coated Non-Stick Skillet, 10 Inches

$100.00, GreenPan

As outlined previously, ceramic nonstick pans consist of a metal base, usually made from stainless steel or hard-anodized aluminum, and feature a layer of silica-based coating that ensures they remain highly nonstick for several years. Each manufacturer uses a slightly different composition for this coating; thus, over many years, we have tested numerous ceramic nonstick pans to identify those that most effectively fulfill their promised nonstick performance.

In 2007, GreenPan was the pioneer with its ceramic non-stick cookware, and since then, their offerings have continually ranked highly in our evaluations. Best Nonstick Pans testing of products at this location as well as over at our affiliated website Epicurious For quite some time now, their Paris Pro series has been an excellent choice for many home chefs due to several factors. The cookware feels robust thanks to its substantial build yet remains light enough to handle effortlessly. Its price point ensures that replacing it down the road won’t strain your finances, and notably, during tests, we found that dishes slipped off it with ease.

A drawback of the Paris Pro is that it doesn’t support induction cooking. For those using induction stoves who prefer a ceramic nonstick pan, we suggest choosing the Valencia Pro as an alternative option currently available. top pick In the Epicurious product review, our testers highlighted its even weight distribution and ergonomic handle, as well as how rapidly it heats up and performs exceptionally with its non-stick coating—without needing any additional oils or butters. Given its higher cost compared to the Paris Pro model, we're only endorsing this pan specifically for those using induction cooktops who require such compatibility.

Stainless steel

All-Clad D3 Stainless 3-Ply Bonded Cookware; Sauté Pan including Lid; 3 Quarts

$180.00, All-Clad

All-Clad D3 Stainless Steel 3-quart Saucepan including Lid

$120.00, Amazon

All-Clad D3 Stainless Steel 14-inch Pan Along with Its Cover

$250.00, All-Clad

Stainless steel cookware is essential in both domestic and commercial kitchens due to its adaptability, robustness, and minimal upkeep. It can be utilized on the stove top, inside an oven, or paired with metallic utensils—a stark contrast to more fragile ceramic pans, as a stainless steel frying pan has the potential to last you many years. Moreover, when used correctly, stainless steel behaves almost like a non-stick surface. Ensuring that your food releases effortlessly rather than getting glued down requires adequate use of fats and appropriate temperature levels. Simply ensure that your oil reaches a glistening state prior to introducing what needs to be cooked; this will prevent sticking effectively.

Over the years, we've put numerous kinds of stainless steel cookware through our tests here at BA, and one brand keeps impressing us with its reliably excellent quality, durability, and performance. This standout brand is All-Clad.

In our testing of stainless steel frying pans and saucepans Product testers and editorial staff from the test kitchen both praised All-Clad’s D3 Everyday line as offering the finest balance between cost-effectiveness and functionality for home chefs. The "3" denotes this range's tri-layer design, composed of an aluminum center encased within dual layers of stainless steel. This composition ensures rapid and uniform heat distribution, along with making the pans lighter compared to purely stainless-steel options. During our evaluations, we confirmed their claims; the D3 series proved simple to maintain—simply rinse them under warm water mixed with dish soap before giving them a gentle scrub by hand. Bar Keepers Friend If you need assistance removing any leftover pieces), they have consistently performed well throughout the numerous years we've used them.

Cast iron

Lancaster No. 8 Cast Iron Pan

$175.00, Lancaster Cast Iron

Lodge 10.25 Inch Pre-Seared Cast Iron Pan

$24.00, Lodge Cast Iron

If you're ready to invest some effort into maintaining your cookware, a cast-iron skillet can easily take over the role typically filled by non-stick pans in your kitchen. While cast-iron won’t match the slick surface of a Teflon-coated utensil, during our tests, we discovered that well-maintained cast-iron performs admirably. properly-seasoned A cast-iron skillet rivals ceramic nonstick cookware—and it actually becomes smoother with each use over time.

Following extensive trials involving over 20 cast-iron skillets spread across multiple years, our present favorite is the Lancaster No. 8 due to its light weight, smoothly seasoned surface that feels non-stick straight away, and excellent heat dispersion. However, this comes at a higher price point. For those looking for an affordable option, we suggest the Lodge cast-iron skillet. It's widely recognized as "the" classic cast-iron skillet and typically costs about $20, making it highly cost-effective considering how long-lasting it is compared to needing frequent replacements. During our tests, it matched up favorably against pricier options but was noticeably bulkier than newer lighter designs such as the aforementioned Lancaster model.

The Le Creuset Signature Dutch Oven, 4.5-quart size in Flame color

$390.00, Le Creuset

Lodge 4.5-Quart Dutch Oven

$116.00, Amazon

It’s possible you might have come across it as well. enameled cast iron , commonly found in items such as our beloved Le Creuset and Staub Dutch ovens. A lot of individuals assume that enameled cast iron cookware should be nonstick due to their resemblance to the light-colored interior surfaces mentioned earlier, which somewhat mirror certain types of ceramic nonstick coatings discussed previously; however, this isn’t actually true. This does not imply that your meals will stick when using them though—just like with stainless steel pans, they require an adequate amount of oil and proper heating techniques for optimal cooking performance.

Carbon steel

OFFER: Merten & Storck Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel Skillet, 8 Inches

$30.00, Amazon

Carbon steel sits right in the middle when it comes to cookware because it offers the non-stick properties and light weight similar to those found in coated nonstick pans, along with the robustness of cast-iron or stainless-steel skillets. However, for these desirable non-stick features, you do have to invest some time initially. properly seasoning Your new pan. However, with some initial effort and periodic upkeep, you'll end up with a cherished piece of cookware that boasts a naturally non-stick surface through wear and tear.

If we had to suggest a skillet for beginning your adventure into carbon steel cookware, we would definitely choose the 10-inch version from Merten & Storck. Priced below $40 when this article was written, it arrives preseasoned and prepared for immediate use, eliminating the hassle of several rounds of preliminary seasoning. The testers were impressed by its naturally nonstick surface right from the start, remarking that "a fried egg glided smoothly off as though it were coated in Teflon." While perhaps not the most visually appealing pan available, it proves itself to be durable and reliable, making past experiences with traditional PTFE-coated nonstick skillets seem obsolete.

Additional cooking utensils where you may find PTFE could appear

When you hear "nonstick cookware," a skillet likely comes to mind first. However, PTFE coatings can also be found in various other kitchen and non-kitchen products. Below are some instances where you might encounter this material in your cooking utensils along with alternative options we suggest.

Rice cookers

OFFER: GreenPan Bistro 8-Cup Carbohydrate-Reducing Rice Cooker

$190.00, GreenPan

Aroma 2.5-Cup Rice Cooker

$40.00, Amazon

Most of the rice cookers available nowadays—including those at the top of our product tests—come with a PTFE-coated inner pot. This is quite beneficial considering how sticky rice can be. We believe that the more consistent heat distribution and reduced friction experienced by the inner pots in these appliances compared to something like a skillet make us worry less about potential wear and tear on the PTFE coating. However, should you prefer another option, GreenPan offers a model featuring a ceramic non-stick coated inner pot. fared well In the Epicurious product test, several models include a stainless steel pot, similar to this one. 2.5-cup model from Aroma .

Waffle irons

Waffle irons often come with a non-stick surface, which is quite logical considering the adhesive consistency of the batter. Fortunately, one of our favorite The winning products come equipped with a ceramic nonstick interior. Similar to the rice cooker, since a waffle iron doesn't experience as much scraping or daily use as a regular pan, the ceramic coating is likely to maintain its nonstick qualities for an extended period.

Bakeware and sheet pans

OFFER: Nordic Ware 3-Piece Bakers' Delight Collection

$40.00, Amazon

Generally speaking, we do not usually suggest using bakeware or sheet pans with nonstick coatings of any kind. If you're planning to bake something seasonal, loaf cake or preparing a batch of muffins It's generally best to use both oil or butter along with parchment paper to make sure you can effortlessly remove your baked goods from their containers later on. Regarding baking sheets, we prefer the uncoated aluminum varieties from Nordic Ware; they're surprisingly simple to clean using only a sponge and soapy water, particularly when you bake directly on them without adding any parchment or aluminum foil.

Sources

• https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/the-long-strange-history-of-teflon-the-indestructible-product-nothing-seems-to-stick-to-180984920/
• https://time.com/6284266/pfas-forever-chemicals-manufacturers-kept-secret/
• https://www.earthisland.org/journal/index.php/magazine/entry/teflons_toxic_legacy/
• https://www.manufacturingdive.com/news/the-history-behind-forever-chemicals-pfas-3m-dupont-pfte-pfoa-pfos/698254/
• https://www.epa.gov/pfas/our-current-understanding-human-health-and-environmental-risks-pfas